The Four Philosophical Definitions Of Justice - 1840 Words

The Four Philosophical Definitions of Justice Richard DeVivo PSC 200-1001 Prof. Bradley 9 February 2015 In Books I and II of The Republic of Plato Translated by Allan Bloom, there many definitions of justice. Socrates knows the definition from the start of the discussion but he wont reveal the definition until he believes Cephalus, Polemarchus, Thrasymachus, and Glaucon come up with their own definitions of justice. If they are wrong the discussion continues until they reach consensus, which is hard for them because Socrates masks his definition pretty well. For them to come up with a definition they have to look at the big picture. In book I they talk about what it means to be just. In book II they talk more about justice in the city as a whole. So in order to figure out what the true definition of justice is, you have to look at the big picture otherwise the definition can be skewed. Lastly you have to develop the definition yourself and learn and further develop your definition from talking with other people because that is the best form of education. In Book I Cephalus is the first one to give a definition of justice. His first definition that he gave was â€Å"shall we simply assert that it is the truth and giving back what has a man taken from another (Bloom 331C).† Socrates then says that this definition is hard to disprove. â€Å"I understand,.. A man does not give what is owed in giving back gold to someone who has deposited it, when the giving andShow MoreRelatedJustice Is The Best Choice For Its Own Sake1307 Words   |  6 PagesRepublic, is a classic philosophical novel that covers many points and topics regarding philosophy. One of these main points includes justice. In this essay I will be answering the question of whether justice in soul is choice worthy for its own sake. While this topic is quite complex, I will use a mixture of personal analysis as well as evidence from the book itself to assert that justice in soul is the best choice for its own sake. In the following paragraphs I will discuss what justice in the soul isRead MoreEssay on Community Policing and Problem-Oriented Policing1408 Words   |  6 Pagesdifference between the two. For one, community policing has many definitions. For some, it means instituting foot and bicycle patrols and doing acts pertaining to the ideal bond between police officers and their community. While for others it means maintaining order and cleaning up neighborhoods in desperate need of repair (Dunham Alpert, 2005). However, an idyllic definition of community policing is altering the traditional definition of crime control to community problem-solving and promising toRead MorePhl/215 Philosophy Matrix988 Words   |  4 PagesUniversity of Phoenix Material Philosophy Matrix   Ã‚  Field |   Ã‚  Definition | Historical Developments  Ã‚   |   Ã‚  Schools Of Thought |   Ã‚  Key Contributors  Ã‚  Ã‚   |   Ã‚  Principal Issues | Epistemology | The study of knowledge: What constitutes knowledge, the nature of knowledge, and whether knowledge is possible | Pre-Socratics observe and seek to define physical phenomena.Socrates studied human behavior and tried to determine the essential nature of knowledge.AristotleRead MoreMy Personal Nursing Philosophy726 Words   |  3 PagesThe integration of nursing theories with a philosophical perspective lays the framework for nursing practice (McCurry, Revell Roy, 2008). My philosophy of nursing is to provide holistic care meeting the  physical, social, economic, cognitive, and spiritual health of a person. This philosophy embraces the four elements of the nursing metaparadigm, which is person, environment, health, and nursing. While theorists have differing concepts and definitions of nursing, the American Nurses AssociationRead MoreCompare And Contrast Aquinas Virtuous Man And Passions1350 Words   |  6 PagesThroughout the many arguments regarding the relation ship between the virtuous man and passions discussed by St. Thomas Aquinas, one argument, in particular, stands out for its agreement with the philosophical view of the Stoics. While Aquinas is a prominent Catholic philosopher and theologian known for his argumentative style of defending and teaching Catholic doctrine as well as providing insightful and compelling outlooks regarding ethical matters, the Stoics are known for their staunch and whatRead MoreThe Elements Of Nursing Research1431 Words   |  6 Pagesmodel more in depth in order to appropriately apply the research findings to their nursing practice. This article defines a theory and a conceptual model, identifies their major concepts, and summarizes the differences and similarities of the two. Definition and Characteristics of Theory According to Nancy Burns, Professor at Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan, a theory is an integrated set of defined concepts and statements that projects a systemic view of the phenomenon. She contendsRead MoreNatural Law : The Human Conception Of Justice Or Moral Right1181 Words   |  5 Pagesbroadly as a philosophical belief that the human conception of justice or moral right is common to all humans and derived from nature. However it’s definition has been highly debated across history and therefore different definitions must be used as to not misinterpret the ideas and principles of different strains of thought within natural law (Boucher, 2009, P.19). It is also very important to distinguish how rights are understood in natural law, which is another contested definition. Rights in termsRead MoreDefining Characteristics From Western Civilization946 Words   |  4 Pages44). Outlasting monarchies and tyrannies, a democracy is, â€Å"a type of Greek gov ernment in which all citizens, without regard to birth or wealth, administered the working of government; it translates as the power of people† (McKay 45). Although the definition says power of people, the only people with power at the time were free men. Slaves and women were considered to have no rights. Today democracy is seen as the right for all people to have a say in what kind of actions the government takes. It technicallyRead MoreWestern Civilization And Its Impact On Modern Society942 Words   |  4 Pages44). Outlasting monarchies and tyrannies, a democracy is, â€Å"a type of Greek government in which all citizens, without regard to birth or wealth, administered the working of government; it translates as the power of people† (McKay 45). Although the definition says power of people, the only people with power at the time were free men. Slaves and women were considered to have no rights. Today democracy is seen as the right for all people to have a say in wh at kind of actions the government takes. It technicallyRead MoreThe Goals of Hinduism and Buddhism Essay1368 Words   |  6 Pagesimmensely. Both Hinduism and Buddhism are more philosophical than religious. Both describe an all-encompassing philosophy and define existence itself. For instance, the essential Hindu concept defining the individual and his responsibilities is dharma. A convoluted term, dharma is a sense of obligation. One must fulfill his roles in society and the world. Such responsibilities include reproduction and caste duties, but extend into the philosophical realm of peaceful and humble acceptance of ones